Playboy Stock Certificates – New York Post

Dear John: What can I do with these Playboy stock certificates?
By John Crudele

New York PostMarch 19, 2016 | 10:00pm
These old certificates could possibly fetch $60 from collectors, according to Kerstein, founder and chief executive of, which …

Dear John:

Dear John: I found stock certificates for Playboy in a box in my closet. I took them to ScottTrade to sell, but they said they couldn’t help me.

I have been trying to track this down on my own, but got nowhere. Maybe you can point me in the right direction. I know it’s not much money, but it’s mine. B.V.

Dear B.V.: Playboy was taken private in 2011, and shareholders were paid $6.15 a share. You have one certificate for seven Class A shares and another for 21 Class B shares. So, in all, that would have been worth $172.20.

You can still cash these in by contacting Playboy’s transfer agent at the time, American Stock Transfer Co. in Brooklyn. The phone number is (888) 328-5369. There are some forms you will have to fill out.

But there is a lot more to the story about Playboy’s stock.

The certificates you showed me have a picture of a woman in flowing robes holding the globe. There’s a composite of various cities in the background.

These old certificates could possibly fetch $60 from collectors, according to Bob Kerstein, founder and chief executive of, which deals in collectibles. that’s not the most interesting part of this story.

Before the ones you own were issued, Playboy certificates had the image of a naked woman at the top — the February 1971 Playmate named Willy Rey (real name: Wilhelmina Rietveld), who posed for the image when Playboy went public that year.

Those certificates, says Kerstein, are worth between $125 and $150 if they are in gold, and between $150 and $200 if they are blue.

Tragically, Willy Rey died of an overdose of sleeping pills in 1973 when she was 23 years old.

Her image stayed on the Playboy stock certificates until 1990, when the company recapitalized.

Why did Rey’s image get the boot? “The stock certificate quickly became a novelty, and at one point there were about 14,000 single shareholders,” making it costly for the company to keep issuing so many single shares, a Playboy spokesperson told me.
Dear Readers,

Your letters to John Crudele are streaming in fast and furiously, asking Dear John to right the wrongs you’re facing. Because of this influx, The Post Business section will feature more of your inquiries in the hope of helping you with your troubles.

Send your questions to Dear John, The New York Post, 1211 Ave. of the Americas, NY, NY 10036, or

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *